School Research Seminar

Cost-Benefit Norms

Is the cost-benefit administrative state sociologically illegitimate? Does transparency into the consequentialist foundations of policy-making undermine trust in regulatory institutions?  This seminar addresses these questions by presenting results from three survey experiments fielded on over 6,000 respondents. In so doing, it makes three contributions to the study of law and policy.

Theoretically, the project resolves the tension between the idea that some values are sacred and the impossibility of pursuing these values to the exclusion of all others by introducing the concept of cost-benefit norms. Cost-benefit norms are behavioral rules identifying the circumstances that require a symbolic affirmation of a sacred value through the performative rejection of any trade-off. These norms are contingent, and they explain why the same trade-off may be odious in one context and anodyne in another. Empirically, the experiments find that regulatory trade-offs between fatal risks and money are not usually regarded as an expressive denial of the sanctity of human life. Taken as a whole, the data indicates that people are not generally opposed to a cost-benefit analysis, even for life-saving regulation. The third experiment also demonstrates the ambiguity and hence malleability of cost-benefit norms. It thereby illustrates the importance of guarding against experimenter demand effects and social desirability biases in surveys investigating social norms.

While the results do not establish the normative desirability of the cost-benefit paradigm, they suggest the absence of any broad opposition to consequentialism in public life. This finding has implications for the democratic legitimacy of the administrative state and its institutional design.

Seminar Room 2-2,
Level 2, Manasseh Meyer,
Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy,
National University of Singapore
Tue 16 April 2019
12:15 PM - 01:30 PM

Benjamin M. Chen

Benjamin M. Chen

Postdoctoral Research Scholar and Lecturer in Law, Law School, Columbia University New York

More about speaker

Kenneth Paul Tan

Kenneth Paul Tan

Associate Professor, LKYSPP

Seats are limited and will be available on a first-come, first-served basis. Kindly email Siew Ming at to register your interest for this seminar.

Please note that by clicking on the registration link above, you will be directly forwarded to a 3rd party independent site, which is not developed nor maintained by NUS. The website could be subject to data protection and privacy practices and you are encouraged to examine them before proceeding to share your personal data. NUS will collect, use and/or disclose the personal data submitted through this 3rd party independent site for the purpose of scheduling, processing, administration and/or management of the event. Please note that photography, audio and video recording may occur during this event. All photography, audio and video recording may be used by the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy and the National University of Singapore for education, marketing, promotional and/or publication purposes. If you do not wish to have your image recorded or published, for compelling and legitimate grounds relating to your particular situation, please inform our staff.