IWP Research Seminar

The control versus resilience rationale for managing systems under uncertainty

I will compare two rationales for the management of social-ecological systems under uncertainty: control and resilience. The first focuses at system performance, the second at system capacity to cope with change. 

The two schools of thought promote their own legitimacy, but undertake little effort to transcend their own perspective. Though, different scholars have pointed at the necessity of combining control and resilience for managing a system. 

I will synthesize the work in the fields of control and resilience into one coherent conceptual framework and reflect on the question whether control and resilience strategies can be reconciled or whether inevitable trade-offs are to be made. I will introduce a framework contrasting both rationales through their preferred (contrary) system attributes. Next, I’ll discuss the operationalization of these system properties for policy development. 

Policies will generally reflect elements of both control and resilience. There will be trade-offs between preferred system attributes, where development of resilience restricts the development of possible control (and vice versa). The conceptual framework introduced provides a ‘language’ for contrasting and possibly (partly) reconciling the control and resilience rationales. Such a language is crucial for a meaningful policy discourse between actors, because it helps in understanding the implications of different rationales and in comparing alternative policies in terms of control and resilience.

Seminar Room 3-5 
Manasseh Meyer Building 
Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy
469E Bukit Timah Road
Mon 27 May 2019
12:15 PM - 01:30 PM

Dr Arjen Hoekstra

Dr Arjen Hoekstra

Professor in Water Management at the University of Twente, the Netherlands. Visiting Professor at the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy, National University of Singapore.

More about speaker

Dr Leong Ching

Dr Leong Ching

Co-Director, Institute of Water Policy and Assistant Professor, Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy, National University of Singapore.

More About Chairperson